Categories
l

CBT’s Dominance Arose From A Medical Model Paradoxically Most Practitioners Disown It

CBT is heralded as the treatment of choice by NICE,  because it is based on randomised controlled trials of ‘effective’ disorder specific protocols, but most CBT practitioners have paroxsyms at the mere mention of a medical model! This makes it inevitable that there is  going to be a yawning gulf between treatment in the rct’s and in routine practice. In this context it simply is not credible that the generally positive  findings from research will be effectively translated. There is a pressing need to build a bridge between practitioners and those who were involved in high quality rct’s:

A way forward is to acknowledge that there is more than one Medical Model, Dominic Murphy [ The Medical Model and the Philosophy of Science  (2013) in The Oxford Handbook of Philosophy and Psychiatry] recommended the minimalist version of the model which asserts that  ‘…. mental illnesses are regularly co-occurring clusters of signs and symptoms that doubtless depend on physical processes but are not defined or classified in terms of those physical processes’. It is this version of the model that largely underpins the DSM criteria. The minimalist version is in fact quite different to the strong version of the model and rejection of this is not synonymous with rejection of the medical model – the strong version is in many ways a caricature. But caricatures are good for uniting people in what they are against and avoids the difficult question of what they are  for.

Dr Mike Scott

20 replies on “CBT’s Dominance Arose From A Medical Model Paradoxically Most Practitioners Disown It”

05 uncorrected for multiple comparisons Overall Survival Log rank Test p 0 buy cialis on line Although the assist devices are used as a bridge to heart transplantation, mere insertion of a device does not guarantee acceptability for heart transplantation, because contraindications may develop or the device may be inadequate to reverse the effects of hypoperfusion

диски аркана литье апрель кто по гороскопу 16
апреля молитвы чтобы не сбылся страшный сон
гадание по цифрам без нолей как почистить квартиру от негатива и порчи самостоятельно свечкой

ғарыш кемесі туралы әңгіме құрау, ғарыш кеме
4 сынып выбор рации для дальнобойщиков,
рация жеке кәсіпкерді мемлекеттік тіркеу туралы куәлік перевод,
жк мемлекеттік тіркегені үшін алым мөлшері дез-хлор таблетки инструкция по применению, эконорм дез-хлор инструкция по применению

naturally like your web site but you have to check the spelling on several of your
posts. Many of them are rife with spelling issues and
I to find it very bothersome to inform the truth however I’ll definitely come back again.

111 элемент таблицы менделеева, от 5 февраля 2008 года № 104 кыргыз
тили 5 класс жусупбекова гдз ответы, кыргыз тили 5 класс ответы шетел немесе шетел, шетел азаматтарының қазақстанға келуі
егінің бастары перевод, егіннің бастары кейіпкерлері

системы, esf gov kz музыка хиты 2022 скачать, сборник песен 2022 скачать бәйгеторы әбіш кекілбаев идеясы, әбіш кекілбаев
аңыздың ақыры қысқаша мазмұны журналистика как профессия, журналистика университет в казахстане

Leave a Reply