BABCP Response - NICE Consultation January 2022

The Centrality Accorded to an Anxiety Label Determines The Level of Avoidance

 according to a study by Ahuvia et al 2024 [Ahuvia, I., Eberle, J. W., Schleider, J. L., & Teachman, B. (2024, March 21). Anxiety Identity Centrality Is Associated With Avoidant Coping in Anxious Adults. (Link)]. To assess centrality, members of the public scoring highly on a measure of trait anxiety were asked to consider 2 circles, one labelled ‘me’ and the other labelled ‘anxiety’. Then to consider the extent of overlap between the two circles, on a 1-5 point scale, were a one would mean no overlap at all (minimal centrality), to a 5 which would denote total overlap (maximal centrality) and that anxiety was central to their identity.  Their findings applied whether the focus was on situational anxiety or on emotional avoidance. The results stood up when differences in the severity of initial anxiety was taken into account. 

People commonly bestow a mental health label before they first see a mental health professional e.g ‘I have always been a worrier’, without any evidence they are worse in this regard, than anyone else.  Or ‘my father developed dementia, my concentration has become poor, I will probably follow in his footsteps’. On the one hand the label confers a sense of identity but on the other as Ahuvia et al 2024 have suggested, it may result in avoidance of anxiety evoking situations e.g a busy shop, or emotional avoidance e.g non-attendance at a funeral, ‘don’t want to get upset’. The anxiety is thereby perpetuated. 

In principle a psychological therapist could help reduce the overlap of the 2 circles. But centrality has not been a focus in CBT, except in my works on trauma [ I have addressed the Centrality issue with regards to trauma extensively in the clinician handbook ‘ Personalising Trauma Treatment : Reframing and Reimagining’ Routledge (2022) and in the 2nd edition of the self-help book ‘Moving On After Trauma’ to be published in June, by Routledge]. The Centrality framework is also clearly pertinent beyond trauma.

NHS Talking Therapies the main provider of UK primary care mental health services, staff do not make diagnoses. GPs mental health diagnoses are usually vague e.g ‘mixed anxiety and depressive disorder’, but can be more specific, though no more reliable, in the wake of an extreme trauma when PTSD may be opined. It seems likely that most people use largely publicly available information on disorders to explain their difficulties.

In the anti-psychiatry movement psychiatrists are often branded as the villains of the piece for making diagnoses. But their domain is largely restricted to those with moderate-severe impairments, who are at the top of a pyramid of prevalence with the great majority of sufferers being at the base of the pyramid. It is arguably the insidious effects of self-diagnosis that is the bigger problem numerically than those effected by severe mental illness. Most people with a recognised psychiatric disorder are likely to be mildly affected with comparatively few at the moderate-severe end. Judgements at the mild end/difficulties are likely to be the most unsound and it is in this area that self-diagnosis is likely to be most in evidence. In the real-world, self-diagnosis is likely to be far more prevalent than diagnoses made by usually psychiatrists on those with moderate to severe disorder.

A mental health professional can be alert to the sabotaging behavioural and emotional avoidance consequences, highlighted by Ahuvia et al (2024] that can arise from over-identification with a diagnostic label, ‘this is who I am’ and strive to separate difficulties to be addressed from the person. A process akin to stopping a person with a physical disability defining themselves in terms of it. But the lay person who has self-diagnosed is likely less equipped to address the centrality issue.


Dr Mike Scott

7 replies on “The Centrality Accorded to an Anxiety Label Determines The Level of Avoidance”

In my experience, anyone stupid enough to go near a psychiatrist or psychologist with the knowledge of an NHS doctor, will never be taken seriously again for the rest of their lives, and will very likely die from an otherwise curable physical condition as a result of their foolishness. Doctors already believe most of their patients are lazy hypochondriacs: go to a psychiatrist and that’s proof. Push for proper diagnostic effort, and you get sectioned and forced to take useless meds for something you don’t have, and lose years of your life until they get fed up of trying to force you to believe your obvious physical signs and symptoms are not real. When they finally kick you out to try and find a doctor who will try to actually find out what the real disease is, with no help from the NHS with even finding you a GP, there will be no apology and you won’t be able to find a medical negligence solicitor who will help you under legal aid.

Without Google, Wikipedia, and money to buy test materials and one’s own diagnostic equipment, it’s amazing anyone ever gets properly diagnosed with anything correctly at all. Doctors don’t have the time, and far too many just don’t care, and know the patient is powerless to do anything about it.

Stay away from all things psych, and, at least, you will get treated with respect for a while longer, if you have a problem that is easy to identify inside 5 minutes with minimal equipment…

And don’t imagine actually being a psych yourself will help you, once you get the label. Chronic illness groups are full of psychs who got turned on by their own when they found out the hard way that their patients weren’t just ‘thinking themselves ill’.

Good luck.

Nəticə: Azərbaycanda onlayn lotereyaların gələcəyi 10line loto apk , 10 Lotto Online platformasının Azərbaycan lotereya səktöründə təsirinin nə olduğunu və bu sektörün inkişafına necə təsir etdiyini araşdırır. Bu, onlayn lotereya oyunlarının özəlliklərini və bu sahədəki yeni iradları təhlil edir. 10 Lotto Online, Azərbaycanda onlayn lotereya təcrübəsinin gələcəyini dəyişdirə biləcək bir mərkəzi rol oynayır və bu sənədlər, lotereya sənayesinin dərinliklərinə daxil olmağa kömək edir.

It’s my belief that mesothelioma is definitely the most deadly cancer. It has unusual features. The more I actually look at it a lot more I am sure it does not respond like a true solid human cancer. In the event that mesothelioma is usually a rogue virus-like infection, in that case there is the probability of developing a vaccine along with offering vaccination for asbestos exposed people who are vulnerable to high risk with developing future asbestos related malignancies. Thanks for sharing your ideas for this important health issue.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *